Posts

Showing posts with the label Documentation of the process

Interviewing José Orraca

Image
José Orraca and Alejandra Mendoza, May 9, 2009, Sharon, Connecticut

Calendar of performed interviews

Number, date, interviewee’s name, interviewee’s title, main institution name, institution location; (Interview location, if different from the first). 1) Monday January 26, 2009 - Tom Edmondson , Conservator in private practice, Heugh-Edmondson Conservation Services LLC, Kansas City, Missouri; (Tucson, Arizona). 2) Wednesday February 4, 2009 - Gary Albright , Conservator in private practice, Honeoye Falls, New York. 3) Saturday February 7, 2009 - Grant Romer , Director of the Advanced Residency Program in Photograph Conservation, George Eastman House, Rochester, New York. 4) Wednesday February 11, 2009 - Peter Mustardo , Conservator in private practice, The Better Image, New Jersey-New York City; (New York, New York). 5) Thursday February 12, 2009 - Nora Kennedy , Sherman Fairchild Conservator of Photographs, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, New York. 6) Tuesday February 17, 2009 - Debbie Hess Norris , Chair of the Art Conservation Department, University of Delaware, Newark, D...

Final Interview questionnaire

Current Status of Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation Interview questionnaire a. Could you please tell me your name, job title and affiliation? b. When was this conservation lab established and for how long have you been working here? (if applicable) c. Could you describe your clientele? [for private practice] Definition 1. How do you define treatment? Need 2. How do you determine the need for treatment? 3. Would you propose the establishment of a regular treatment program for the collection? [for institutions] Type & Aim 4. What is the scope of treatments that you perform and the types of photographs you treat most frequently? 5. What is the aim of the treatments? 6. Could you describe, as an example, the intervention of a photograph you treated (methodology followed)? 7. How do you evaluate treatment results? Degree/Extent of intervention 8. What do you consider as a minor, moderate and major intervention? 9. Do you consider the creation and application of secondary ho...

A little "research" into YouTube

Image
Defining a publishing system for interviews: YouTube? The use of YouTube to make interviews accessible: If you type the word interview in you tube: 853,000 videos available Themes, titles, contents, lengths vary diametrically. Although most interviews last less than 10min, there are some longer than 60min as well. Examples of videos related to photographs :

Testing YouTube embedding

Image
This is a test from YouTube embedding, also a test for the use of titles and covers using i-movie. YouTube is a possibility for publishing the interviews. It is an accessible diffusion tool, that has already been used by academic purposes. Some of the inconveniences are that when a video is uploaded to YouTube, it loses context and that "similar" videos are related to it, which can be completely different and unrelated. [In the original posting, the video was uploaded to you tube but it was removed after 2 months, since it was only a trial. During this time, 35 people viewed the video and none left a comment on it].

Rehearsal interviews with ARP Fellows

Image
Rehearsal interviews with ARP Fellows Yesterday I interviewed two of my co-fellows at the Advanced Residency Program: Ania Michas and Hyejung Yum (separately). The purpose of this was both to try the questionnaire (version 6) and potentially evaluate the answers, as well as to improve my interviewing skills. I gave them the interview questionnaire 1 and 2 days before the interview (posted Jan 6, 2009) and used the version with notes and follow ups (posted Jan 5, 2009) as planned. I think that both interviews went pretty well. Interestingly the answers from one interviewee to the other were very different, which somehow reinforces the value of collecting different points of view on the topic and the range of perspectives towards conservation treatments. The length of each interview was 33 and 34 minutes. The observations I made in terms of the structure and content of the questionnaire are: - At the beginning, a deeper conversation about the interviewees previous experience was needed i...

Changes from version 4 to version 5

In the template 5 I slightly reformulated some of the questions of the first part of the interview (trying to avoid tendencies or bias). Also, I developed the fourth treatment topic question -about modern and contemporary photography. This version of the interview questionnaire is ready to be tested.

Interview questionnaire (from version 5)

This is the questionnaire that I am sending to the interviewees prior to the interview. It derives directly from template 5, but it more direct and simple. Current Status of Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation Interview questionnaire a. Could you please tell me your name, job title and affiliation? b. When was this conservation lab established and for how long have you been working here? (if applicable) c. Could you describe your clientele? [for private practice] Need 1. How do you determine the need for treatment? 2. Would you propose the establishment of a regular treatment program for the collection? [for institutions] Type & Aim 3. What is the scope of treatments that you perform and the types of photographs you treat most frequently? 4. Could you describe, as an example, the intervention of a photograph you treated? 5. What is the aim of the treatments? Degree/Extent of intervention 6. What do you consider as a minor, moderate and major intervention? 7. Do you consi...

Template for interviews, version 5

Current Status of Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation Interview questionnaire (template 5) a. Could you please tell me your name, job title and affiliation? b. When was this conservation lab established and for how long have you been working here? Need 1. Considering that in practice, not all deteriorated photographs (or not all photographs that present problems), can be treated or are treated, how do you select and prioritize the photographs that are going to be treated? What factors determine the need or request for treatment? 2. If you had more resources would you propose the establishment of a regular treatment program for the collection? (based on surveyed priorities?) Type & Aim 3. Can you describe the scope of treatments that you perform and the types of photographs you treat most frequently? 4. Could you describe, as an example, the intervention of a photograph or group of photographs treated in this lab recently, to help me understand your work methodology? (A c...

Description of the project

After producing the first questionnaires and analyzing the project scope, it was decided that the interviews would only include North American Conservators (conservators working in US). After presenting the project at the George Eastman House in December 2008 , the project description had evolved to the following: Current Status of Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation Statement of Purpose This research will create a basic reference resource (interviews-based) that describes and addresses the current status of treatment within the profession, its philosophies, history; and the criteria and methodologies used for its evaluation. The objective of this resource is to gather and make accessible the knowledge and experience of a group of key individuals in the field, answering fundamental questions that relate to our work. Significance Treatment is one of the activities that characterize and differentiate a photograph conservator from other closely related specialists. The possibil...

Changes from version 3 to version 4

In template 4 I incorporated new questions regarding treatment types and types of treated photographs, to complement the first part of the interview. Also, I developed the third treatment topic question -about unmounting/remounting photographs.

Template for interviews, version 4

Institutions Could you please tell me your name, job title and affiliation? When was this conservation lab established and for how long have you been working here? I. -My next question relates to need for treatment. Considering that in an institutional reality, not all deteriorated photographs or not all photographs that present problems, can be treated or are treated, how do you select and prioritize the photographs that are going to be treated? What factors determine the need for treatment? [Potential answers: Exhibition/loan; established treatment plan/program; specific projects] -If you had more resources would you propose the establishment a regular treatment program for the collection? (based on priorities) -Broadly speaking what types of photographs are treated most frequently? [Paper based photographs (traditional processes: salt prints, albumen prints, silver gelatin, platinum prints, pigment processes, cyanotypes), daguerreotypes, other early cased photographs, modern and con...

Template for interviews, introduction version 4

Template for interview Today is Day, Date (month, day, year), Time. My name is Alejandra Mendoza and I am with (name of the interviewee) to have a conversation about Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation. This interview is/forms part of the series of interviews I am conducting to photograph conservators to investigate and describe the current status [state] of treatment practices in our field, the general characteristics and objectives of the interventions performed, and the variables that influence its performance, as well as briefly address the transformation of treatment standards and decision-making through time. I would like to follow a format for the interview in which I will begin asking you questions about the approaches, characteristics and extents of the treatments performed in this institution, followed by questions addressing treatment issues that the field has faced through time.

Changes from version 2 to version 3

I continued developing new questions and question structures for the beginning of the interview. With this initial section, I am trying to contextualize what treatments are being performed, where, how often, to what degree. I realized -after feedback with faculty members- that the idea of inquiring about difficult treatment study cases, may sound too rigid or violent for the interviewees. And therefore I decided to structure the questions by treatment topic. Instead of asking, "what would you do if a client brings you an object with this problem?", asking "what is your opinion about this treatment? Do you think it can/should be performed? when, why? This approach gives more space for conversation and can be better understood.

Template for interviews, version 3

Institutions Could you please tell me your name, job title and affiliation? When was this conservation lab established and for how long have you been working here? I. My next question relates to need for treatment. Considering that in an institutional reality, not all deteriorated photographs or not all photographs that present problems, can be treated or are treated, how do you select and prioritize the photographs that are going to be treated? What factors determine the need for treatment? [Potential answers: Exhibition/loan established treatment plan/program specific projects] If you had more resources would you propose the establishment a regular treatment program for the collection? -In a general sense, what is the aim of the treatments performed, stabilization or restitution of the aesthetical qualities of the object? (Or both?) [Cleaning, consolidation, flattening, structural repair, compensation for loss/inpainting] - Do you consider mounting and rehousing as conserva...

Changes from version 1 to version 2

I realized that the heading "Philosophy and Ethics" was hard to understand, and that the questions could be addressed differently and in a different order. I introduced the idea of presenting specific case studies to talk about complicated treatment procedures. For example, intensification of prints or album dis-assemblage. The shape or content of these questions are not definitive, just a trial.

Template for interviews, version 2

Today is Day, Date (month, day, year), Time. My name is Alejandra Mendoza and I am with (name of the interviewee), to have a conversation about Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation as part of my project for the ARP in which I intend to describe the current status of treatment practices: its characteristics and objectives, and the variables that influence its performance; as well as briefly address the transformation of treatment standards and decision-making through time. I would like to follow a pattern for the interview in which I will begin asking questions about the approaches to treatment in this institution, its characteristics and extents, followed by questions about the similarities and differences compared to the treatment practices performed in other types of institutions. After this, I will present to you some [3] hypothetical treatment cases to hear your opinion about them and end up with some questions about education. To start, could you please tell me your name...

Progress: Statements

After the last weeks I came up with some "statements" that I would like to prove (wrong or right) through my project Current Status, - Treatment is performed in different “places” responding to different needs: * Private Practice (for museums, private owners, galleries, auction houses) * Art Museums * Archives * Regional Centers * Historical Societies Therefore, - Treatments performed are different - Treatment(s) goals/specific objectives are different - Allowable/suitable/appropriate treatment and treatment extents are different Statements: - Treatment is not performed on all photographs - A greater recognition/understanding of the values of a photograph and its subtleties, has lead to less intervention - Treatment is driven by other activities and social phenomena such as: *Exhibition *Market *Fashion/Perception of how a photograph should look - Treatment decision-making is performed by a group of people From the meeting (with Grant), we concluded I should define hypot...

Feedback: Pau Maynés

Today I spoke with Pau Mayés about my project. I think I still can not explain it in simple ordered ideas. Somehow, the fact that I want to focus in understanding and describing the current treatment practice got lost in the conversation and I couldn't bring it back. When he read my proposal he centered his attention in the evolution of treatment criteria. He suggested me to narrow the topic into one concrete theme, like that one. He shortly referred to his project (Oral History of Photograph Conservation) and his experience. He said that now he knows he would have done things differently, but didn't say how. When he read the topics for the question he said "philosophy" is an abstract big word, that nobody understands. When he read my questions (posted Oct.26) he said they were too theoretical and felt like an exam. He suggested me to use concrete examples as ground for discussion. He gave me some suggestions of bibliography to look for (some of which I have already c...

Template for introduction of interviews- version 1

Today is Day, Date (month, day, year), Time. My name is Alejandra Mendoza and I am with (name of the interviewee), to have a conversation about the Current Status of Treatment Practices in Photograph Conservation. I would like to follow a pattern for the interview that includes questions about the philosophy and ethics of conservation treatment, following a discussion about the current status of treatment practice, treatment evaluation and education, continuing with aspects about the progress and transformation... [order to be defined] To start, could you please tell me your name, your current job position, the institution or company that you work for, and for how long have you being working here? I would like to begin with..